Metaphor and Perception in Wine Criticism
“This sexy, opulent, complex, and perfumed Pomerol is fleshy, silky, and luscious in its elegant, feminine style.” (Robert Parker)
Such wording evokes an image of pure femininity.
The notion that wine can embody femininity is a fascinating perspective, one deeply embedded in wine criticism and description. The use of gendered metaphors in the wine world is widespread, offering a more vivid and evocative way to communicate a wine’s intricate characteristics.
Robert Parker’s description is a prime example of how gendered attributes can be used to personify wine. This approach goes beyond mere flavor analysis, instead painting a sensory portrait that immerses the reader in the experience of the wine.
A closer examination of my years of collected wine notes—from various media sources, authors, wine enthusiasts, and my own observations—reveals a striking stylistic trend: an equilibrium between feminine and masculine adjectives. Here is my personal interpretation of the metaphorical language used in wine criticism, highlighting the feminine characteristics often ascribed to wines.
Sensory Attributes and Gendered Metaphors – Aromas and Textures
Wines often described as feminine are associated with attributes such as elegant, floral, silky, and delicate. These terms evoke refinement and grace, qualities culturally perceived as feminine.
Body and Structure
Feminine wines tend to have a smooth, velvety texture and a subtle tannic structure. Rather than relying on sheer power, they emphasize finesse and balance.
Examples of Wines Described as Feminine
Burgundy Wines (especially Pinot Noir): Frequently described as delicate, elegant, and refined, these wines excel in presenting complex aromas of red fruits, flowers, and fine spices without overwhelming their structure—an aspect often interpreted as feminine.
Champagne: Particularly Blanc de Blancs made exclusively from Chardonnay grapes, often labeled as graceful, feminine, and delicate. The fine bubbles and fresh, floral aromas reinforce this perception.
Wine Descriptions and Cultural Perceptions – The Subjectivity of Wine Language
The use of gendered metaphors in wine descriptions is deeply rooted in cultural tradition. How people perceive aromas, textures, and structures is influenced by societal norms and personal experiences.
Striking a Balance
Historically, wine descriptions have balanced both masculine and feminine attributes. While bold, tannic wines are often characterized as robust, powerful, and structured, equally frequent are feminine descriptors applied to wines that exhibit subtlety, elegance, and complexity.
Subjective Perception and Consistency – A Matter of Individual Experience
Describing a wine as feminine is inherently subjective, shaped by individual perception and experience. Factors such as taste sensitivity, sensory awareness, and personal preference all play a role.
No Definitive Trend
Historically, there has been no clear shift toward either more masculine or more feminine terminology. This suggests that the gendered characterization of wines remains largely a matter of subjective interpretation rather than a fixed linguistic evolution.
Conclusion
While there is no scientific evidence that wine possesses inherent femininity, the rich and metaphorical language of wine criticism provides ample examples of gendered descriptions. These descriptors help wine lovers better appreciate and articulate the nuances and complexity of wine. The balance between masculine and feminine attributes underscores the diversity of wine styles and highlights the inherently subjective nature of wine language.
– – –
Photo Credit: © Adobe Stock/Avve Diana
